Schools, businesses look for ways to conserve energy

By David Poulson
Lansing Bureau


  • As California deals with rolling blackouts, Michigan puts the focus on conservation.

    LANSING -- It's almost a mantra among state and utility officials seeking to calm the fears of Michigan electricity-users: Unlike energy-starved California, we are not gripped by the specter of rolling blackouts this summer.

    But the effect of California's energy woes are rippling across Michigan as business owners, sensing a new cost-cutting frontier, seek to shave energy needs.

    "It's safe to say there is an increased sense of awareness out there since what happened in California," said Martin Kushler, director of the utilities program for the nonprofit American Council for an Energy Efficient Economy.

    Most energy efficiency efforts are concentrated in states such as New York, Massachusetts, New Jersey and Connecticut, which help businesses and residences implement them with public funding, said Kushler, who recently completed a survey on the issue.

    Michigan once had a similar program financed by rate payers, but it was discontinued in 1995 under intense pressure from utilities and energy-hungry industries that did their own improvements and didn't want to finance improvements for others.

    Still, Michigan business operators are launching their own efforts, even experimenting with voluntary brown-outs.

    The 150-store Grand Rapids-based Meijer Inc. chain recently started an intense evaluation of how many lights it needs. Potential annual savings of $30,000 to $50,000 per store are huge in an industry looking for fresh ways to cut overhead, company spokes-man John Zimmerman said.

    "Utility expenses are the largest controllable expenses in our stores," Zimmerman said. "Sometimes we have a tendency to flood in as much light as possible. Now we're finding that we can reduce utility expenses while giving light to our product. If you have one area covered by five lights and you really only need three lights, we remove two of them without impacting the sales floor."

    Jackson Public Schools, the county's largest school district, also has entered into its own energy-saving effort, hiring an "energy cop" last year who has looked to cut costs. The school system has saved $152,000 just since Dec. 1.

    "We're just trying to be more efficient in what we're doing," said Jeff Huey, the district's energy control engineer. "We're still trying to offer the same programs."

    Often businesses can use new technology to cut costs and improve how light makes their products look, said Mike Halbeisen, a consultant with The Energy Concern, a South Haven business.

    "If you are a retailer and selling something in a blue box or a red sweater, it's going to look better when you walk into a store we've done," he said.

    He attributes the increasing business at his four-year-old company in part to the trend toward deregulating energy industries.

    "Everybody thought the utilities were a monopoly, and they thought that you just have to bite the bullet and that's the way it is," he said. "They never paid attention to gas and electricity."

    His company has tackled jobs as diverse as changing the lights in the nationwide Family Video Store chain, and suggesting that a hockey rink use its own generator to keep the ice hard when utilities charge a premium for power during peak demand. Other clients include college campuses, public schools and manufacturers.

    The attraction is that the energy gains finance the cost of improvements, Halbeisen said.

    "Right now, the opportunity in the state of Michigan is in getting energy efficient," he said. "We're showing some pretty good returns on investment."

    Improving energy efficiency can diminish the state's need for hard-to-site power plants and reduce pollution. But to maximize those benefits, Kushler, who previously supervised energy efficiency programs for the Michigan Public Service Commission, says they need public investment.

    "The economics of energy efficiency are positive and a smart business owner should do it," Kushler said. "The problem for most businesses is that they don't have experts on staff, and they are much more focused on running their business. It takes organized programs to recruit businesses and show them this is a safe and smart thing to do."

    Those who are opposed to mandatory government programs insist that energy prices will drive improvements. The recent volatile natural gas prices have already driven improvements, said Bob Strong, a lawyer for the Association of Businesses Advocating Tariff Equity, a group of large Michigan industries that fought government efficiency programs.

    "That has been a shock to everybody's budget, and in the industrial world, one of the worst things that can happen is that the budget gets blown away by unanticipated cost increases."

    Even without taxpayer dollars, however, Consumers Energy has worked with large manufacturers for several years to use energy more sparingly. Spokesman Dan-iel Bishop said Consumers employees visit business sites and work with employers to go beyond the simple task of turning off the lights in an empty room.

    Many residents, too, have been more efficient with energy use, if only because of more efficient furnaces, he added.

    In general, Bishop said, Consumers hopes to encourage all customers not to waste energy.

    "The message we're attempting to certainly get out this summer," he said, "is that now is the time to think about energy conservation."

    -- Staff Writer Brian Wheeler contributed to this story.